Comments

  1. Jon says:

    I’m not presbyterian, but I am a designer and I feel bad for any group to have to choose from this pool of designs. Go back to the drawing board.

    that being said… 14 isn’t terrible.

  2. ryan pappan says:

    Thanks Jon.

  3. Jim Kennedy says:

    # 14 is in a class by itself. “Beatiful”

  4. Jeff Harris says:

    What’s the attraction to #7 ? Looks like it belongs on a gum wrapper or oil can. 14 is the best with a clear message.

  5. John Vest says:

    How do you vote for the variations of 14? I like the ones without the text best.

  6. Ashleigh says:

    Jeff,

    Like I said before, I think most of them are too big. 5, 7, and 15 seem to be the only ones of reasonable size, and I like 7 the best of those.

    I do really like 1, but I can’t tell what it is (it looks cool as a design, but isn’t a good logo, in my opinion), and I also really like 14, but again, there’s the size issue, I think. (But if I didn’t feel like 14 were too big, it’d probably be my favorite– I do like the concept)

    Some of the others are ok, but several I’m not really attracted to at all.

    As far as 7 resembling an oil can label, I think quality graphics are important, but can’t we critique art without hurling insults? I’m sure there are more constructive, less hurtful ways of criticizing others’ submissions.

  7. neil craigan says:

    not crazy about any of them, think we need a do over. If I vote it would be for #14.

  8. Jen Reeve-Parker says:

    I like #14

  9. Clay Thomas says:

    i know this was last year’s conversation, but i find myself drawn back to some of these images and would like to use some of them as backgrounds in worship and/or watermarks on bulletins.

    i don’t want to rip off an artist though. so can folks give me a green light if they are okay with the use of the creations in worship

    especially 1 and 10-14.

    pax
    clay

  10. Dow says:

    All these looks like the 60′s. The Swiss designs are more modern. You’ll want a logo that remains strong 10 years from now. Designs are expressions of the meaning. None of these tells me what Presbymergent is and still don’t know what it is. I would design a logo to illustrate what Presbymergent is so the viewer wouldn’t have to look up it’s meaning.

Speak Your Mind

*